- Barney Gothelf
- Blake Matthew Gothelf
- Celia Gothelf
- Charlotte Hoskwith Gothelf
- Cooper Stuart Gothelf
- Ethel Gothelf
- Gotlieb Gothelf
- Hyman Gothelf
- Ida Gothelf
- Issac Gothelf
- John Sol Bluestein Gothelf
- Leo Gothelf
- Lillian Gothelf
- Louis Gothelf
- Max Gothelf
- Mildred Gothelf
- Murray L. Gothelf
- Myles Stuart Gothelf
- Nathan Gothelf
- Sarah Gothelf