- Abie Godfrey
- Abraham E. Godfrey
- Alexander Godfrey
- Anne Tollinsky Godfrey
- Arnold Bernard Godfrey
- Arthur Godfrey
- Bella Godfrey
- Benjamin Godfrey
- Benjamin B. Godfrey
- Dinah Godfrey
- Eli Godfrey
- Eli A. Godfrey
- Elias Mary Godfrey
- Ella Godfrey
- Ethel Godfrey
- F. I. Godfrey
- George Godfrey
- Harry Godfrey
- Herman Godfrey
- Jacob Godfrey
- John T. & (Mrs.) Godfrey
- Joseph Gerald Godfrey
- Laizer Godfrey
- Lily Wiseman / Wiseberg Godfrey
- Mabel Godfrey
- Mary Godfrey
- Mathilda Godfrey
- Matilda Godfrey
- Michael Aron Godfrey
- Miriaam Godfrey
- Miriam E. Godfrey
- Murray Godfrey
- Pearl Godfrey
- Philip Godfrey
- Rachel Godfrey
- Rebecca Godfrey
- Reuven Godfrey
- Richard W. Godfrey
- Richard Wallace Godfrey
- Robert E. Godfrey
- Rubin Godfrey
- Sadie M. Godfrey
- Samuel Godfrey
- Sarah Leah Godfrey
- Sylvia Godfrey
- Walter Godfrey