- Albert Gerstley
- Anna S. Gerstley
- Florence A. Gerstley
- H (Mrs) Gerstley
- H. Gerstley
- Henry Gerstley
- Henry (Mrs) Gerstley
- Henry (Mrs.) Gerstley
- Henry M. (Mrs.) Gerstley
- J (Mrs) Gerstley
- Jennie R. Gerstley
- Jesse Gerstley
- Jesse R. Gerstley
- Julius Gerstley
- Katie Hartman Gerstley
- Lewis Gerstley
- Louis Gerstley
- Louis (Mr) Gerstley
- Louis (Mrs.) Gerstley
- Louis and William Gerstley
- M (Mrs) Gerstley
- M.M. Gerstley
- Margaret M. Gerstley
- Norbert Gerstley
- Robert Gerstley
- Samuel A. Gerstley
- Sophia Gerstley
- Sophia (Mrs) Gerstley
- Tbeodor D Gerstley
- Theodore D Gerstley
- William Gerstley
- William (Mr) Gerstley
- William (Mrs) Gerstley
- William (Mrs.) Gerstley
- Wm. Gerstley